Genealogy Beginnings

Several years ago I became interested in the genealogy of my family when I was given a “starter page” of information compiled by another family member on my father’s side of the family. My mother’s family had plenty of information and photos of generations gone by, so I had a lot to go on there. However, on my father’s side, there were very few photos and even less information.

This “starter page” looked fairly straightforward, but as it turned out there were a lot of twists and turns along the way and things were more complicated than it would seem at first glance.

 

My Starter Page - Many Thanks to the Author

My Starter Page
Click to Enlarge

 

To continue my story, I was trying to trace my father’s family back further in time. I knew that his grandfather’s name was James Smith, born in Ontario, with a father named Robert Smith born in Scotland. My grandfather’s name was Robert Robertson Smith. This was certainly not much information to go on but it was a start.

 

Great grandfather James Smith 1865-1920

James Smith 1865-1920
great-grandfather

 

I did some searching through dusty microfiche files at the library, looking for anything that could have provided a lead of some sort. There were no clues at all and my research became even more puzzling. I was able to find records for several James Smith born around 1865  with a father named Robert Smith but none seemed to be a good match with my limited information.

After a while and with a subscription to Ancestry, I again began looking through these perplexing records which I was now finding online. On Ancestry, I found several extensive family trees containing various Robert Robertson Smith’s from Ontario. I thought that since my grandfather’s middle name was Robertson that the Robert Robertson Smith name may have been passed down.

The most prominent Robert Robertson Smith (1810-1899) had immigrated to Canada from Scotland in 1931 and had married a woman named Elizabeth Callaghan from Ireland. Following this discovery, I proceeded to examine his family tree carefully – 16 children in all and, yes, a Robert Robertson Smith (1844-1941) as one of the sons.

 

Robert Robertson Smith 1810-1899 3rd great-grandfather

Robert Robertson Smith
1810-1899
3nd great-grandfather

 

There were photos of these two Robert Robertson Smith’s which particularly caught my interest. I could see resemblances to myself and other family members. My instinct told me that these two were my ancestors but the proof was not yet there.

Robert Robertson Smith (1844-1941) was born in Ontario and had moved west to British Columbia at some point. He died in Salmon Arm, British Columbia.

 

Robert Robertson Smith 1844-1941

Robert Robertson Smith
1844-1941
3rd great-uncle

 

My grandfather, Robert Robertson Smith,  was born in British Columbia so I speculated that this Robert Robertson Smith from Salmon Arm could very likely be my great-great-grandfather, father of great-grandfather James Smith.  However, there was no record of him having a son named James.

By this time I had a fairly large tree with this family on my Ancestry site but connecting it to great-grandfather James Smith eluded me. I still felt that this was my family from the photos, the stories and just an unexplained sense of knowing. There were many documents and records to back up the information in this family tree but still no way to connect it to great-grandfather James Smith.

Finally, in 2013, the brick wall came tumbling down, only because I noticed (Steele) in parentheses on another person’s Ancestry tree in reference to a James Smith who married a Mary Remi. James Smith and Mary Remi, I knew already, were my father’s grandparents. Also, other persons from my then known family tree were in her tree.

After emailing the Ancestry member, I received a response that gave me enough information to confirm that James Steele, already in my “unproved” family tree, actually was my great-great-grandfather, James Smith. James Smith (Steele) was, in part, raised by his mother’s father, Robert Robertson Smith. Robert Robertson Smith’s daughter, Mary had been married to a Thomas Steele who died of a fractured skull from a falling tree in 1872 when son James was about seven years old.

 

Thomas Steele (1843-1872) 2nd great-grandfather

Thomas Steele
1843-1872
2nd great-grandfather

 

At some point after the 1881 Canada Census where he appears as James Steele living in Ontario and before the 1891 Canada Census where he appears in British Columbia as James Smith, James Steele took his grandfather’s and mother’s original surname and became known as James Smith.

Also, I have received (incredibly) a copy of a personal letter from great-grandfather James Smith written to his sister  Mary Ellen Steele in 1896.

 

2nd great-grandmother Mary Smith 1842-1895

Mary Smith (Steele)
1842-1895
2nd great-grandmother

 

This letter was very enlightening in describing some of the family history that may have contributed in bringing a young James Smith from his family in Ontario to a new life in British Columbia – more about this in a future post!

I have since had confirmation through my AncestryDNA test that I am indeed related to this family. Some of my DNA matches also had family trees that matched my own so I was able to determine exactly how we were related and at times obtain more history and interesting stories about our mutual ancestors.

 

2 Comments

  1. I am in absolute awe of the information you have posted. I was conducting a simple google search while looking for information regarding one of my Great Aunts… Jane C Holmes. You can imagine my surprise when your work turned up as I am a Great Granddaughter of Mary Ellen Steele (Henderson).

    • Thanks Kari!

      We had some correspondence in 2016 when you sent me a copy of a handwritten letter from my great grandfather James Smith to his sister Mary Ellen Steele (Henderson) and her husband Wallace Henderson, along with a portrait of Mary Smith (Steele) who is the 2nd great grandmother of both of us, with her second husband Andrew Forrest.

      The letter from James Smith was very interesting and gave insight into the family history. James Steele changed his name to James Smith at some point after the 1881 Canada census. This name change was the reason I had originally had difficulty in connecting with the Smith family descending from Robert Robertson Smith (1810-1899) although I somehow already sensed that there was a connection! More explanation is in the post above.

      Best Wishes,
      Eileen

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *